Price tags ending in 9 are everywhere. The studies that Eric Anderson and Duncan Simester cite in their 2003 paper found that between 30% and 65% of all prices end in the digit 9. In the two clothing catalogs they worked with, more than half of the prices did. The obvious guess is that 39.99 feels like 30-something. The two professors, then at the University of Chicago and MIT, wanted to know whether the nine changes what real people buy.
A mail-order company selling moderately priced women's clothing let them run a test. It printed three versions of the same catalog and mailed them to separate groups of customers chosen at random. Four dresses changed price between the versions. The usual price ended in 9, and in the other two versions it was 5 dollars lower or 5 dollars higher.
One dress cost 34, 39 or 44 dollars depending on the catalog. It sold 16 times at 34, 17 times at 44 and 21 times at 39. Across all four dresses, the prices ending in 9 sold 66 units, against 46 at the lower prices and 45 at the higher ones. The 10 dollar gap between the two other versions made almost no difference.
That first test was small, so the professors ran three bigger ones with two catalogs, mailing up to 90,000 customers per version. In the first, with 20,000 customers per version, a price ending in 9 raised demand by about 35%. The nine helped in all three studies, and it helped most on new items, the ones shoppers had no old price for.
Their explanation is that shoppers use the ending as a clue. Stores tend to put a 9 on prices that are low compared with other shops, so customers learn to read a 9 as a sign of a good price. That fits another result from the third study. When an item already carried a Sale sign, adding a 9 seemed to help less, a result the authors call tentative, as if the sign had already done the nine's job.