Many dog owners are sure their dog wakes them up at night. Researchers at the University of Toronto Mississauga decided to measure it instead of asking. They recruited 25 people in southern Ontario and their 38 dogs, all huskies and malamutes between 2 and 12 years old, and fitted both sides with the same MotionWatch 8 activity sensor: a wristband for the person and a collar sensor for the dog. The sensors counted movement every minute for about four weeks, from November 2 to December 9, 2021.
The first result was about the people. On average they slept 6.23 hours a night, with a sleep efficiency of about 79 percent. Whether the dog slept on the bed, sometimes on the bed or never on the bed made no measurable difference to either number. Most owners agreed with the sensors: 14 of the 25 said their dog never woke them, nine said once or twice, and two said more than twice. The only thing linked to worse sleep was living with more than one dog, and that showed up only in how people rated their sleep, not in what the sensors recorded.
The second result was about timing. The team could analyse 36 owner and dog pairs, and in 22 of them the two moved within five minutes of each other. In 10 of those pairs the person usually moved first and the dog followed. In only 4 did the dog usually lead, and in the other 8 they moved in the same minute. All four dogs that led were sleeping off the bed.
The authors are careful about what this means. The sample was small, almost all the owners were women, and the data were collected during COVID lockdowns, when routines were unusual. A sensor also cannot tell a dog dreaming from a dog getting up. They call the question in their title, who is disrupting whom, still open, but the numbers they have point at the human side of the bed.