Do people pay more with a credit card than with cash?

In an MIT auction for the same Celtics tickets, students told to pay by credit card bid 60.64 dollars on average and students told to pay cash bid 28.51, a gap of 113 percent.

In the spring of 1992, two professors at MIT's Sloan School of Management, Drazen Prelec and Duncan Simester, ran a lunchtime auction in a classroom. MBA students answered a poster that promised a 2 dollar bill and a chance to buy Celtics tickets. The main prize was a pair of balcony seats for the Celtics' last regular season game, against the Miami Heat on Sunday, April 19. The game was sold out and the Celtics needed the win to take their division. Red Sox bleacher seats and a pair of team banners were up for auction too.

Every student wrote down the most they would pay for each prize. The auction used second price rules, where the top bid wins but the winner pays the second highest bid. Under those rules nobody gains anything by bidding more or less than a prize is really worth to them.

The only difference was hidden in the instructions. Half of the sheets, handed out at random, said the winners had to pay in cash. The other half said payment would be by credit card and asked for the card type, its expiry date and the last digits of its number.

The 31 students in the cash group bid 28.51 dollars on average for the Celtics tickets. The 33 in the card group bid 60.64 dollars, 113 percent more. The Red Sox tickets showed the same pattern, 9.02 against 15.92 dollars, and so did the banners. All of these amounts are in 1992 dollars.

Could the card group just have been short on cash? The researchers argue that this can't explain a gap this size. The median cash bid was 25 dollars and the median card bid was 41, so a student would have been accepting a 64 percent surcharge just for the right to pay by card. They published the results in 2001 in the journal Marketing Letters, under the title "Always Leave Home Without It".

A second study in the same paper used a restaurant voucher good for up to 175 dollars, a prize with its value printed on it. When students only stated how they would pay, cash and card bids came out about the same. A smaller gap of 36 percent appeared among students who had copied digits from their card onto the sheet.

Questions people ask

Who ran the credit card auction experiment?

Drazen Prelec and Duncan Simester, professors at MIT's Sloan School of Management. They published it in 2001 in the journal Marketing Letters.

Were the students just short on cash?

The researchers say that can't be the whole story. The median card bid was 64 percent above the median cash bid, and they found it hard to believe that MBA students would accept a 64 percent surcharge just for the privilege of paying by card.

Does the card effect show up for everything?

Not always. In a second study the prize was a restaurant voucher with its value printed on it, and the gap between cash and card mostly disappeared. The effect was largest for tickets with no price on them.

What the video says

  1. With a credit card, people bid double what cash payers bid.
  2. In 1992, researchers at MIT put a pair of sold-out Boston Celtics tickets up for auction.
  3. Students in a classroom each wrote one secret bid, the most they'd pay.
  4. Every bid sheet was the same except for one sentence. Half the sheets said pay in cash, and half said pay by credit card.
  5. Students told to pay cash bid just over 28 dollars on average for the two tickets.
  6. Students told to pay by card bid just over 60 dollars on average, more than double.
  7. And every bidder was an MIT business student, the people you'd expect to know better.

Source

Always Leave Home Without It: A Further Investigation of the Credit-Card Effect on Willingness to Pay (Marketing Letters 12:1, 5-12)

Marketing Letters, MIT Sloan, 2001-02-01

Read the source

Also in Spanish