Why did a Coca-Cola cost 5 cents for over 70 years?

A 6.5 ounce Coca-Cola sold for 5 cents from 1886 until 1959. Economists Daniel Levy and Andrew Young traced it to a bottling contract and, later, to about 400,000 Coke vending machines that mostly accepted a single nickel.

From the first glass poured at Jacobs' Pharmacy in Atlanta in 1886 until 1959, a 6.5 ounce Coca-Cola cost 5 cents. Economists Daniel Levy and Andrew Young documented it in a 2004 paper in the Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, using the company's own archive and the papers of its longtime president, Robert Woodruff, at Emory University. They call it a price that stayed put for more than 70 years, through two world wars, the Great Depression and sugar rationing.

The first lock was a contract. In 1899 the company gave bottling rights to two Tennessee lawyers, with the right to buy syrup at a fixed 92 cents a gallon forever. When sugar prices jumped after the First World War, the company was losing about $29,000 a day, and it only got a new deal in 1921, with the syrup price tied to sugar. By then the bottlers had every reason to keep the bottle itself at a nickel.

The second lock was the vending machine. Coin coolers spread from 1936, and by 1950 there were about 400,000 Coca-Cola vending machines, most of which took one nickel and nothing else. Machines that made change existed from 1946, but the authors estimate that replacing the old ones would have cost between about 413 and 566 million dollars in 1992 prices.

The third lock was the coin in your pocket. The next coin up, the dime, would have doubled the price, and Woodruff feared that people would not pay 10 cents for 6.5 ounces when a 12 ounce Pepsi cost a dime. Anything in between meant handing over a pile of small coins.

So Woodruff asked his friend President Eisenhower in 1953 to have the Treasury mint a 7.5 cent coin, and Treasury officials turned it down. Coca-Cola's pricing team also drew up a Single Coin Plan: a machine that, for one nickel in every nine, would deliver an empty bottle or no bottle at all, which works out to 5 and 5/8 cents a Coke on average. By 1955 a Coke cost 5, 6, 7 or even 10 cents depending on the town, and by 1959 the nickel Coke was gone.

Questions people ask

When did Coca-Cola stop costing 5 cents?

The price started to break in the 1950s. Time magazine reported a 6 cent Coke in New York City in 1950, and by 1959 the last nickel Cokes were gone, according to Levy and Young.

Did Coca-Cola really ask for a 7.5 cent coin?

Yes. Levy and Young report that Robert Woodruff asked President Eisenhower in 1953 to have the Treasury mint a 7.5 cent coin. Eisenhower passed the request to the Treasury, whose officials did not like the idea. A note in Woodruff's papers suggests he also thought about a 3 cent coin.

Why didn't Coca-Cola just charge a dime?

A dime would have doubled the price at once. Woodruff worried that buyers would not pay 10 cents for a 6.5 ounce Coke when a 12 ounce Pepsi cost a dime, so the company looked for a price in between.

What the video says

  1. A Coke cost a nickel from 1886 to 1959. Two world wars and pricey sugar never moved the price.
  2. By 1950, Coca-Cola wanted to charge more. But its 400,000 vending machines mostly took only nickels.
  3. Charging a dime would double the price, and Coke's boss feared sales would crash.
  4. Coke's boss even asked President Eisenhower to make a coin worth seven and a half cents.
  5. Treasury officials said no. So Coke's planners drew up a sneakier machine.
  6. One time in nine, the machine would take your nickel and drop an empty bottle.
  7. The sign would still say five cents, but you'd pay for nine Cokes and drink eight.

Source

"The Real Thing": Nominal Price Rigidity of the Nickel Coke, 1886-1959 (Levy and Young, Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, vol. 36 no. 4)

Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, Bar-Ilan University, 2004-08-01

Read the source

Also in Spanish